Whisky news from around the world

American Whiskey

Four Roses Single Barrel offers better value than Blanton’s

Four Roses Single Barrel provides superior flavor and higher proof for approximately $40, making it a better value than Blanton's Single Barrel which starts at $72. The comparison highlights differences in mash bills, aging processes, and tasting notes between the two bourbons.

Four Roses Single Barrel offers better value than Blanton's

Price and production specs

I select Four Roses Single Barrel over Blanton’s because it delivers superior flavor for nearly half the price. Buffalo Trace makes Blanton’s using Mash Bill #2 and sources it from Warehouse H, which Buffalo Trace calls "the only metal-clad warehouse at Buffalo Trace." Elmer T. Lee, then the distillery’s master distiller, introduced Blanton’s in 1984 as the first single barrel bourbon sold commercially. He named the whiskey after his mentor, Albert B. Blanton, a former distillery manager who was known for pouring whiskey from his favorite "honey barrels" for visiting guests. This bourbon typically ages six to eight years and carries a 93 proof (46.5% ABV) rating.

Feature Blanton’s Single Barrel Four Roses Single Barrel
Proof 93 (46.5% ABV) 100 (50% ABV)
Age Range 6-8 years 7-9 years
US Price Starts ~$72 (up to $120) Starts ~$40
UK Price £72 to £90 Starts ~£43

Four Roses produces its Single Barrel using the OBSV recipe with 60% corn, 35% rye, and 5% malted barley paired with the "delicate fruit" V yeast strain. This Four Roses expression ages seven to nine years and hits 100 proof (50% ABV) in both the US and the UK. E. & J. Gallo completed its purchase of Four Roses from Kirin in April, and master distiller Brent Elliott and his team remain at the distillery. Blanton’s starts at approximately $72 in the US, but some retailers charge as much as $120. Four Roses starts around $40, so you can buy two bottles of Four Roses for the price of one Blanton’s depending on where you shop. In the UK, you can expect to pay around £80 for Blanton’s, though the cheapest listed on our comparison site is £72 at Royal Mile Whiskies, while the price climbs to £90 on Amazon.

Tasting comparisons

Flavor profiles separate these two Kentucky bourbons. Blanton’s presents a nose of nutmeg, honey, vanilla, orange citrus, baking spices, and toasted oak. The palate begins sweet before moving into orange, lemon, and brown sugar with follow-up notes of vanilla, rye spice, and oak. Its medium finish brings caramel, leather, oak, pepper, and a light touch of tobacco. Phil Dwyer gave Blanton’s an 8/10 in his review, but I find it hard to justify the Blanton’s price on flavor alone.

The Four Roses Single Barrel provides a more intense experience. The Four Roses nose presents spiced and fruity notes including pear, peaches, vanilla, milk chocolate, cinnamon, nutmeg, caramel, butter, and nuts, which transitions into a palate of butter, caramel, cherry, peach, wood spice, dark chocolate, mint, rosemary, and cinnamon. The finish lasts a long time with fizzy cherry sweets, caramel, butter, and a medicinal hint of rosemary and lemon. Phil Dwyer gave this bottle a 9/10. I reach for this bourbon again and again because it is a real bargain.

Choosing the right bottle

I recommend Four Roses Single Barrel for drinkers who want quality without the premium markup. While Blanton’s remains a popular gift because of the iconic bottle and the horse-and-jockey stopper, the flavor alone does not justify the extra money. Elmer T. Lee based Blanton’s on the idea of bottling individual standout barrels. Each bottle carries one of eight letters in B-L-A-N-T-O-N-S, and Buffalo Trace adds the stoppers at random. Four Roses redesigned its bottles in 2023 by adding a raised rose emblem on the front and an engraved rose design on the cork.

Finding a bottle is easier with Four Roses than with Blanton’s in both the US and the UK. Blanton’s availability remains a hurdle for many bourbon lovers, though the price has risen sharply in the USA. Four Roses has kept its price steady for the last five years. While Blanton’s could vary widely barrel to barrel, Jordan Moskal at Breaking Bourbon noted that it "rarely does." If you are buying for someone who will enjoy displaying the bottle as much as drinking what is in it, Blanton’s is a better gift, as long as you are comfortable with the higher price. I would buy Four Roses Single Barrel every time for its flavor and its value.