Low and mid-range comparisons
Symington’s 10 Year Old Blended Whisky beats Glen Moray 12 Year Old Single Malt in a $30 price test. Symington’s comes from Andrew Symington, the owner of Edradour Distillery and Signatory Vintage independent bottlers. I find the 46% ABV Symington’s to be a rich, decadent blended whisky with dried citrus, sherry notes, soft biscuits, and honey. The finish lingers with a gentle sherry sweetness. The 40% ABV Glen Moray 12 Year Old is a light, sweet, and approachable single malt with flavors of green apples, pears, vanilla, and caramel. This 12-year-old single malt is an excellent introduction to Scotch. I prefer the Symington’s because the higher ABV and sherry influence deliver more flavor for the money.
Compass Box Nectarosity wins the $60 round against Glendronach 12 Year Old. Nectarosity is a blended malt, not a single malt, using whiskies from Cameronbridge, Girvan, Linkwood, Clynelish, and Balmenach. This lively 46% ABV whisky provides flavors of butterscotch, apricots, nectarines, pineapple, buttery pastry, and warm honey. The Glendronach 12 Year Old is an extraordinary 43% ABV single malt that provides orange, chocolate, raisins, and wafer biscuits, followed by a warming finish and a nutty sherry sweetness. While the Glendronach is a good bottle that remains cheaper than many competitors, the price has crept up since the distillery is no longer independently owned. I choose the Nectarosity because its fruit and caramel flavors provide a freshness that stands out.
High-end price comparison
Old Pulteney 15 Year Old takes the $100 comparison against Ballantine’s 17 Year Old. Ballantine’s 17 Year Old is a 40% ABV blend with aromas of apples, pears, mango, and coconut. This well-aged whisky is one of the best-known expressions in a range that includes numerous age statements and styles. I feel the flavors of the Ballantine’s need a higher ABV to provide more weight and a longer finish. The 46% ABV Old Pulteney 15 Year Old is an underrated, non-peated coastal single malt with sherry cask influence. It provides a full and rounded palate of honey, red fruit, poached pears, caramel, milk chocolate, raisins, and orange oil. The saltiness of the coastal malt gives it character, and the finish seems to go on forever. I recommend Old Pulteney because its higher ABV and sherry influence provide more weight and complexity than the Ballantine’s.
| Whisky | Type | ABV | Price |
|---|---|---|---|
| Symington’s 10 Year Old | Blended | 46% | $30 |
| Glen Moray 12 Year Old | Single Malt | 40% | $30 |
| Compass Box Nectarosity | Blended Malt | 46% | $60 |
| Glendronach 12 Year Old | Single Malt | 43% | $60 |
| Ballantine’s 17 Year Old | Blended | 40% | $100 |
| Old Pulteney 15 Year Old | Single Malt | 46% | $100 |
The blends won two out of three rounds. I suggest Glen Moray and Ballantine’s if you prefer light, easygoing whiskies. I recommend Old Pulteney for those seeking bigger flavors and complexity.
